Amtrust North America o/b/o Justin McGinness v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company
Amtrust North America o/b/o Justin McGinness v. Liberty Mutual Insurance Company is one matter in the Veritas record of US court proceedings involving AI-generated citations that could not be verified against the reporters named. The summary below is drawn from the underlying court document, linked at the foot of this page.
- Court
- SC New Jersey
- Date
- March 27, 2026
- Party
- Lawyer
- AI tool
- Not identified in the order
- Outcome
- Monetary sanction: $1,000
- Penalty
- $1,000 in monetary penalties.
What the record shows
The Appellate Division found counsel's appellate brief cited four cases that do not appear in the New Jersey Superior Court Reports, which the court described as hallmarks of generative AI, and that counsel failed to correct the brief or withdraw the citations after defendants flagged them. The court imposed a $1,000 sanction on plaintiff's counsel.
This entry reflects the court document as filed. The citations at issue could not be located in the reporters named at the time of the order. The reading here is descriptive of the public record and is not legal advice.
Source documents
The test this filing did not run
Every matter in this record shares one mechanism: a citation that did not resolve to an opinion in the reporter named, in a brief that was filed before any verification step ran. Veritas runs that step. The Filing Risk Scanner extracts each citation, resolves it against reporter and public-record sources, and returns a verdict on each one — located, partial, or not located in reporter — before the brief is signed.
Run a free reviewBack to the full tracker →